For live music fans, what was supposed to be the so-called "hot vax summer" has begun to feel more like "Delta variant downer." The recent COVID surges around the country are putting a damper on the joys of finally experiencing live music again even as major festivals and concerts return. It's also putting organizers and artists in the music industry in an increasingly tricky and uncertain position.
A roaring, hopeful return, interrupted
As soon as guidelines for fully vaccinated adults relaxed a few months ago, music festivals and concert venues kicked into gear, announcing dates and artist lineups. With so much pent up demand for the thrill of sharing live music with crowds of strangers, tickets to many of these events were snapped up by eager homebound audiences.
"Magical," is how Michelle Joy, lead singer of the up and coming band Cannons describes performing at Lollapalooza in Chicago last weekend. It was the band's first festival ever. "We've been working so hard for an opportunity like this," she says. "So we have spent a lot of time thinking about how we can make this safe and not let the virus also kill our dreams." To that end, the band members are fully vaccinated but still wore masks when they weren't performing, even though they weren't required.
Lollapalooza's rules for returning were strict by all measures. Festival goers had to show proof of vaccination or a negative COVID test result obtained within 72 hours of entry. Only unvaccinated people had to wear masks. Even though a video emerged online that appeared to show those protocols weren't always adhered to by attendees, Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot told WVON-AM on Tuesday that she was confident they made the festival as safe as they possibly could, including having City of Chicago staff make regular visits to the screening checkpoints.
Lightfoot also revealed that Chicago's Public Health Commissioner went to Lollapalooza "incognito." Lightfoot says Dr. Allison Arwady didn't have the proper paperwork. "They wouldn't let her in. Every single day," says Lightfoot, screeners "turned hundreds of people away."
Did Delta turn off the carefree vibe?
Still, even with protocols like those at Lollapalooza in place, there are many in the industry and the medical community who think these kinds of massive gatherings remain unsafe. As NPR has reported, the delta variant appears to be around twice as transmissible as the original SARS-CoV-2 strains.
On social media, some are using dark humor to express their disbelief, imagining what a feast these festivals must be for the coronavirus. One Twitter user posted a photograph of an exhausted basketball player keeled over with the caption "Covid after running rampant at Rolling Loud and Lollapalooza."
Covid after running rampant at Rolling Loud and Lollapalooza pic.twitter.com/E4v8edmLd7
— Inoki (@_dwet) July 30, 2021
Marianne Shanley, who lives in Brooklyn, has taken to social media to express her anger over New York City's plans for several, largescale outdoor concerts with such marquis stars as Bruce Springsteen and Jennifer Hudson. Shanley says she "physically felt ill" when she saw the photos of tens of thousands of bodies pressed against each other at Lollapalooza.
"I feel like there's enough evidence to know that these large gatherings at this point in time are going to be hugely problematic and seed the country for another catastrophic winter," says Shanley.
Epidemiologist Dr. Eric Feigl-Ding believes "music festivals and concerts are risky." In an email to NPR he writes, "mostly because of the...indoor gatherings after hours and crowded bathrooms."
Please don't stop the music
Artists have been booked. Tickets have been sold. Stagehands and other workers have been hired. The music industry's reopening train left the station months ago. So how should festival organizers and concert venues respond to the increasing risks?
"I don't think that the events should be canceled," says Dr. Leana Wen, an emergency physician and public health professor at George Washington University. "I know that there are calls for them to be. But we have to recognize as a society that we're now going to be living with risk, that nothing that we're going to be doing at this point is zero risk from COVID-19, from spreading COVID, from getting COVID."
Dr. Wen says, to "make the events as safe as possible" audience members should be required to show proof of vaccination. "We know that getting vaccinated protects you extremely well from getting severe illness and also reduces your likelihood of getting COVID and therefore of transmitting it to others." Dr. Wen says to further reduce the chance of a super spreader event, venues could also require proof of a negative test. These measures might even "incentivize" more people to get the shots, she says.
A performing arts economy bruised but not broken
The arts and entertainment industries have been devastated by COVID. The vast majority of musicians only get paid when they perform. Chad Smith, CEO of The Los Angeles Philharmonic Association which oversees The Hollywood Bowl, says as soon as county and state health departments announced they could open up at full capacity, "we did."
"The mood with artists and the community and audiences has been celebratory, up until this point."
The legendary outdoor theater has a capacity of nearly 18,000. It's first concert back — the July 4th Fireworks Spectacular with Kool and the Gang — sold-out. Smith says it "was an incredibly emotional time ... I don't think I've ever heard the National Anthem sung so loudly."
Smith agrees that the "delta variant is a concern." He says they surveyed their patrons and found "that close to 98 percent of the people who are coming to The Hollywood Bowl are vaccinated." Currently at The Hollywood Bowl masks are required when indoors and whenever attendees are not in their seats.
That is some comfort to Geetanjali Dhillon who recently attended a Ziggy Marley concert at The Hollywood Bowl, a venue she says is "a place of such great community for Los Angeles." But she admits the uncertainty around the delta variant prevented her from fully enjoying the experience. "I didn't even realize it until I got there and then started to feel a little bit of anxiety because it was a massive crowd and I had not been in a crowd like that in...about a year and a half," says Dhillon.
Those public health officials and programmers advocating for a sustained return hope that a blend of audience anxiety and desire will motivate live music lovers to be extra careful — and get vaccinated — so shows can go on.
Cannons' lead singer Michelle Joy believes, in the age of COVID, it'll come down to personal responsibility. "If everyone does want to go to these festivals and stuff, there's a part that they have to play to keep themselves and everyone safe," says Joy. "And we're personally trying to do that. And we hope that other people do that as well."
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org. 9(MDA4MzM1MjM1MDEzMTg5NTk0MzNmOTQ5MA004))
