Legal Challenges Expected To DeSantis Order Against Mask Mandates In Schools
A leading education lawyer said Monday that Governor Ron DeSantis’s executive order banning school districts from requiring masks appears to violate the state constitution, and will likely lead to legal challenges as Florida schools prepare to open next week amid a surge in cases of coronavirus.
“The governor and the commissioner of education (Richard Corcoran) are simply removing the authority from local elected school boards, which flies right in the face of the constitution,” said attorney Ron Meyer.
“The governor seems to have created the authority for this anti-mask decree out of thin air.”
Meyer cited Article 9, Section 4 of the Florida constitution, which states: “The school board shall operate, control and supervise all free public schools within the school district.”
That language “is pretty plain that local school districts, elected by local citizens, have the power to operate, control and supervise public schools in the district,” he said.
“In the absence of extraordinary circumstances, which would be codified in an emergency declaration — and we don't have that — you have to look at the constitution and how the people of Florida said their schools should be operated,” Meyer said in an interview with WUSF.
On Monday, Florida set a new record for most people hospitalized with coronavirus cases on a single day, with 10,682 statewide, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. That topped the state’s previous record set on July 23, 2020.
It also came after Florida reported its highest single day total of new coronavirus cases, with 21,683 recorded Friday.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the American Academy of Pediatrics both recommend universal masking in schools for those over age 2, as the nation sees a rise in cases of the highly contagious delta variant of coronavirus.
DeSantis’s executive order, issued Friday, says CDC guidance on masks for children “lacks a well-grounded scientific justification.” It also cites H.B. 241, the “Parents Bill of Rights” the Republican governor signed into law in June, as barring the state from infringing on the fundamental rights of parents to make health care decisions for their children.
“He's giving lip service to relying upon the parental rights legislation House Bill 241. But that's a bill that confers rights on parents, not on the governor. So we question really whether what the governor has done is constitutional,” Meyer added.
The order also says the Florida Board of Education has the authority to withhold funds from any district that fails to comply with the executive order, which amounts to what Meyer called “bullying school districts to carry out (DeSantis') mandate.”
The Tallahassee-based attorney said he is semi-retired after practicing education law for almost 50 years, and is not personally pursuing any litigation, but expects to see legal challenges arise.
“I think we will see litigation over this. We should see litigation over this. Because I think it's just once again putting political interests ahead of child welfare. And that's just never been a good thing.”
Copyright 2021 WUSF Public Media - WUSF 89.7. To see more, visit WUSF Public Media - WUSF 89.7.